Comments - Chris Harris takes Camaro ZL1 and Mustang GT500 to NYC

Published: Jul 06, 2012
Description: Motoring in Manhattan is a frustrating endeavor, but the New York skyline makes a particularly gritty backdrop against which to compare the pinnacles of the muscle car scene.
Add Comments 50
Alex Somers Jul 10, 2012
A muscle car is a muscle car u risk gas mileage for power no matter what. It's not ur parents Nissan leaf for a reason
Michael Shurtz Jul 09, 2012
For those who would choose the camaro over the mustang for a day to day driving car think about it. The camaro is good for day to day driving but you have terrible gas mileage and have to pay gas guzzlers tax while the mustang has better gas mileage and does not have to pay tax so the mustang is for me no matter what!
Peter Mark Gacek Jul 08, 2012
I'll take them both without stripes in either black or light grey.
Read Mills Jul 08, 2012
I think that many people often forget that stock muscle cars are a blank canvas. They are cars that are sold with un-tapped potential that the owner can unlock through modding.
Laguna Seca Jul 07, 2012
God bless them both, love them. When the ZL-1 fixes that interior I will buy one.
Alex Somers Jul 07, 2012
Big cars are great but with a bit of tuning with the super charger on the zl1 it could be running 740 hp and 780 ft. Lbs. torque. They had to tune down the zl1 cause they didn't want it out doing the zr1 corvette. I'd rather have the camaro
Steven Velez Jul 07, 2012
@Isaac i read your comments but in my mind i couldn't read it correctly cause i kept hearing it in a screaming voice.
Denise Oman Jul 07, 2012
The Camaro is a much better car.
Scott Lenahan Jul 07, 2012
Finally someone gets the point. It's about the sound, the look, the straight line speed, the absolute scare you get from driving it... Not the speed around tracks and ride quality. I want to be scared to death when I drive the ultimate muscle car, not find it easy.. Love em both, but GT500 wins this one...
Craig Lafey Jul 07, 2012
ZL1 for me. Love em. 2 seconds faster around the track too? Nice.
Cory Wilhelm Jul 07, 2012
It was a great review. And for once no arguing. Also I'm 5'10" and I feel cramped and small in the Chevy. I've been in the mustang and it is easier to see out of. And Shelby for me.
Ethan Amo Jul 06, 2012
Yea, I really gotta admit, both look outstanding, both have the power. They are both awesome...especially in red..
Zeus Mocha Jul 06, 2012
It has visibility issues, trust me, I'm a doctor... Haha I have one and it's not horrible but if you are 6'3" you shouldn't have a problem. If your shorter though, you will have problems looking over the hood and then the stupid A pillar.
Cameron Dean Jul 06, 2012
I'd take both, and a Boss LS
Geoff Novak Jul 06, 2012
But lets be honnest. These cars are awesome :)
Evan Cook Jul 06, 2012
I don't know why some you guys are talking about having visibility isues with the zl1. I'm 6 ft 3 inches and when I sat in one I had to pull the seat forward and I could see fine through all windows.
Michael Riley Jul 06, 2012
it could get more American if you didn't have an accent ;P
Klay Owens Jul 06, 2012
I love them both, but I prefer the cobra over the zl1 any day of the week.
Brady Fereday Jul 06, 2012
Holy cruise control Isaac calm your self
Phillip Holbrook Jul 06, 2012
Yeah they were scary but it was due to a lack of technology not because they wanted it to scare you.
Phillip Holbrook Jul 06, 2012
These are pony cars, the Camaro was called the Hugger back in the day. Do you even know why? Because it hugged the road. For the time the Camaro was possibly the best handling car you could get stock from a factory.
Jesse Andersen Jul 06, 2012
I don't think his figure of $35,000 is true but if it is I may move to England. My opinion is ZL1 is a better built car so who cares how much more HP the Cobra has if you can't stay on the road. Plus, how many of us actually have 600 horses?
Isaac Cerda Jul 06, 2012
AND THIS GUY HAS A POINT FORD SO MUCH POWER BUT CAN B TOUGH SOMETIMES, I OWN A 2013 MUSTANG AND YES THE SHORT SHIFTING AND SLOW DRIVE IS A BIT TOUGHER THEN THE CAMARO, I DROVE MY BUDDIES ALOT SMOOTHER BUT I STILL THINK THE 13 MUSTANGS ARE AMAZING
Isaac Cerda Jul 06, 2012
GLAD THIS VIDEO WAS MADE HOPEFULLY SHUTS UP ALOT OF PEOPLE WHO ARE ANTI MUSCLE CARS AND THINK THEY ARNT GOOD MACHINES.. ID PERFER DRIVING EITHER THEN HAVING A BORING LUXURY GAS SAVING EUROPEAN CAR THAT COST MORE THEN THESE CARS AND HAS HALF THE POWER
Pablo Herasme Jul 06, 2012
I like Camaro too, but I just prefer the power and the stance of the Mustang.
Austin Lark Jul 06, 2012
I have always been a die hard Chevy guy but you just can't help but love the sound and power of that mustang. Yeah I like the looks of the Camaro more and always have through the years but that's all personal opinion. Both cars are awesome machines!
Tino Nickolas Alanis Jul 06, 2012
Both of these gorgeous machines are absolutely sweeeet!!! If I'm picking one though, it's the shelby. I would have way more fun in it, I want something to scare me :)
Taylor Garry Jul 06, 2012
I respect both but as someone said earlier the camaro sucks to be in. Makes you feel tiny
Avery Williams Jul 06, 2012
If I had to choose which one I'd like, I would have to imagine myself on a long highway trip and see which one is fun to drive going a long distance.
Razor Curtiss Jul 06, 2012
I want a muscle car to scare me and acasionally make me shit myself and the camaro just doesn't do it I respect it but the mustang is way better looking and more fun to drive. Which is what it's all about isn't it?
Razor Curtiss Jul 06, 2012
I agree the unbiased European was a great person to do this and the GT500 is still better cus he was driving slow on the track if he tried his best with both cars I'm sure the mustang would win
Kaigan Viner Jul 06, 2012
I'm glad an unbiased European reviewed the two. But the GT500 sounds so good
Chris Mallinson Jul 06, 2012
Fantastic review as always by chris Harris... Follow him on pistonheads.co.uk
Tim Preisinger Jul 06, 2012
I'm a Chevy guy but would still go for the Mustang. I think I would just have more fun with it. I also love to sound of the GT500.
Nick Yekikian Jul 06, 2012
Screw it... I'll take both for the same price as a GTR
Val Barata Jul 06, 2012
Finally someone had a good opinion of the zr1 vs the gt500 XD a muscle car is supposed to be crude, scare you, make you wonder if your getting out of it today. Which mustangs do much better. Who cares which goes around a corner?? ;)
Brady Fereday Jul 06, 2012
And F driving in New York City I would get frustrated and want to punch an elephant lol
Brady Fereday Jul 06, 2012
Challys are nice cars they just need to lose weight
Patrick Schalk Jul 06, 2012
Challys aren't pieces of shit. They are great cars. Obviously I'm already biased but MRC and an LS drivetrain. I'm taking the Z
Hunter Wolfe Jul 06, 2012
Hahaha challengers..... Pieces of shit=O go CAMARO!!
John Serely Jul 06, 2012
the mustang. I do give the camaro credit, though, it's a truly awesome car!
John Serely Jul 06, 2012
For me, I'd take the mustang, I prefer it's looks, and love the sheer power of it. Sure, the zl1 handles better, but if wanted a good handling car that's fast, I'd take a cayman s for the money. That being said, if I want a powerful car, I'll take
William Downs Jul 06, 2012
challenger srt8 cant stand up against these, its outclassed on every level
Zeus Mocha Jul 06, 2012
The beast and the snake. Both cars look amazing and perform great. I wish I could have both. ZL1 for first pick though
Matt Piccolo Jul 06, 2012
I would take the gt500..it looks better and unlike the camaro, U CAN SEE OUT OF THE DAMN THING lol I've been in a camaro and it made me feel like I was 4 foot and could barely see outta the car... But then I realized it wasn't me that was the problem
Barry Boo Wilson Jul 06, 2012
It couldn't keep up to make it to the shoot. SRT needs to step it up.
Mark A. Young Jul 06, 2012
I'm tired of all these articles featuring just the mustang gt500 and the camaro zl1, where's the challenger SRT8?
William Downs Jul 06, 2012
plus id reather have a car thats easy to drive day to day.. but i do give that stang it props thing is crazy
William Downs Jul 06, 2012
na thats personal opinion... i think the camaro looks better then the stang
Carlton Salmon Jul 06, 2012
Given the choice and being a Brit I'd go for the Camaro.
Description: Over recent months, the grudge match between the 580hp Chevrolet Camaro ZL1 and the 662hp Ford Mustang Shelby GT500 has been played out in various guises and with different referees in charge, but the...
Add Comments 0
Peter Mark Gacek Jul 08, 2012
Sorry the GT500 wheels are "similar" but, in my mind, unmistakable with those beauties on the Gallardo LP560-4. Ha
Laguna Seca Jul 07, 2012
The gold Chevy emblem says class, just missing the hairy chest and chains.
Abraham Mendoza Jul 07, 2012
Grabber blue is one hell of a color. I'd get my Camaro in silver with black rims. Boom!!
Matt Piccolo Jul 07, 2012
The red looks really good on the gt500!! Only color I'd rather have it in is the bright blue they come in..
Kevin Hinkle Jul 07, 2012
IMO the zl1 looks better... But the mustang isn't far behind
Thibault Leroy Jul 06, 2012
has anyone else notices that the rims on the GT500 are pretty much the same as the ones on the gallardo LP560-4?
Abraham Mendoza Jul 06, 2012
In yellow, it looks gorgeous.
Jason Villwock Jul 06, 2012
God bless America.
John Serely Jul 06, 2012
As much as I love the mustang, the ZL1 looks badass in yellow
Shane Heid Jul 10, 2012
Your right of they were racing the camaro would be two seconds in front, not just a hundred feet
Matthew Crighton Jul 09, 2012
You can tell they aren't racing... Because the camaro is in front.
Matt Piccolo Jul 07, 2012
I find this funny cuz I find the back of the camaro a lot more attractive than the front but everyone else is opposite... I don't seem to like cars where the headlights are behind (older muscle cars) or in (current camaro, chally) the grill
Zeus Mocha Jul 06, 2012
It's okay, let it all out. It gets people raging haha. Anyways the Camaro's back is ugly. But IMO the front looks killer with the splitter, stacked fogs and the ECF mohawk.
Jack Higgins Jul 06, 2012
I think it's ugly all around. Obviously that's just my opinion. Not that it matters to anyone.
Abraham Mendoza Jul 06, 2012
The camaro does look a bit...ugly from the back but I still love it.
Eric Alcantar Jul 06, 2012
Naaah not from all angles.
Austin Jobes Jul 06, 2012
nahh, the mustang is amazing from all angles.
Kaigan Viner Jul 06, 2012
GT500 looks better from behind but the ZL1 looks a tad bit better in the front